Showing posts with label Newbery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Newbery. Show all posts

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Review: An American Plague

The True and Terrifying Story of the Yellow Fever Epidemic of 1793

By Jim Murphy

Clarion Books; 2003; 165 pages

Non-Fiction; Award Winner: Newbery Honor Book, National Book Award Finalist, Robert F. Sibert Medal Winner

Grades: 6-12

ISBN: 978-0-395-77608-2

This book relates the tale of how the Yellow Fever crippled our nation's capital of Philadelphia. Political bigwigs, such as George Washington and Benjamin Franklin, along with pioneering doctors and a fearful populace were all caught up in the horrific epidemic that changed history.

My Thoughts:
It is obvious why this book has won so many awards. I thought that this was a very well executed, and very interesting book on a topic that I generally do not enjoy reading about. I am not a fan of sickness, or reading about sickness, or reading about the often barbaric practices of early doctors, or reading about political intrigues and ramifications. Yet, for some reason, I really enjoyed this book. For one thing, Jim Murphy is an outstanding writer. The mere mechanics and style of the text pulls the reader in. At the same time, he handles the subject matter in a mature and yet kid-friendly manner. Also, it is beneficial for students to read works like this early in their school careers since it introduces them to several standard non-fiction practices: citation, primary documentation, and quotation. (And does all of this without being dry or boring.)

The book is full of facts that kids will enjoy, especially the section on bleeding people. I think they will be intrigued by the fact that this is still an incurable disease as well. All though the time period and setting won't be familiar to the kids, some of the people described in it will be: George Washington, Dolly Madison, Benjamin Franklin. I think having them in the book helps make it more accessible to children. In addition, the artwork throughout the book does a good job of supporting the text. (Keep in mind though that this is meant for older children, so the artwork is secondary to the text.) I also really liked the facsimiles of newspapers and publications from the time. They added visual interest, but also made for fun reading...especially the bits that had nothing to do with the story at hand!

The Thoughts of Others:
Publisher's Weekly reviewed An American Plague in 2003 and liked how "Murphy injects the events with immediacy." It doesn't seem like it is a history book. Their reviewer also praised the comprehensive nature of the text, liked the photos and appreciated the recommended resources and cautionary note.

Kirkus's Review in 2003 called this book "a mesmerizing, macabre account that will make readers happy they live in the 21st century." They highly praised the prevalence of primary sources, as well as how the "powerful, evocative prose carries along the compelling subject matter."

Saturday, October 25, 2008

Review: Tale of Despereaux

By: Kate DiCamillo

Candlewick Press; 2003; 267 Pages

Juvenile Fiction; Newbery Award Winner

Grades: 3-6

ISBN: 9780763617226

The story of a very little mouse with enormous ears. When Despereaux falls in love with a human princess, the castle culture is rocked to the core. Despereaux is forced into many exciting and dangerous adventures as he rushes to save the girl he loves.

My Thoughts:

I enjoyed this book immensely. I thought that the style was great, reminiscent of early novels from the 1800's, with the narrator often addressing comments directly to the Dear Reader. At the same time the plot moved along at a rapid pace, there were twists and turns through out, and the language was not mired in prohibitive vocabulary. (Although, the young reader will quickly learn the meaning of "perfidy.") I also thought that the plot itself was highly original. Although there have been other stories of princesses, mice, rats, and dungeons, DiCamillo somehow manages to avoid being derivative.

There are several aspects that I truly liked. The first is that soup is central to the storyline. I like soup. The second is that Despereaux is an underdog, and I think that kids will be able to identify with him. No one seems to expect much out of him, and they are easily frustrated when he doesn't fit into thier mold. By maintaining his integrity, he is actually able to do what those who are larger and better qualified cannot. I also loved that the story is not set in a specific era. Though it takes place in a castle, the king is depicted as singing the sixties hit "Deep Purple." Also, no one seems surprised that the animals can talk and interact with the people. Finally, I appreciated that the story teaches certain morals,but is never preachy. It teaches the importance of forgiveness, acceptance, and hope. It also teaches that love, though ridiculous, is powerful.

The Thoughts of Others:

Miriam Lang Budin wrote a review for School Library Journal in which she likened DiCamillo's writing to both Henry Fielding and George Orwell. She summed the work up as "entertaining, heartening, and, above all, great fun."

Booklist's Ilene Cooper appreciated the hidden lessons, writing that, "as with the best stories, there are important messages tucked in here and there, so subtly that children who are carried away by the words won't realize they have been uplifted until much later." She also appreciated the way that DiCamillo seamlessly wove four storylines together.