Review: Cat with the Yellow Star

Coming of Age in Terezin

By Susan Goldman Rubin with Ela Weissberger

Holiday House; 2006; 40 pages

Juvenile Non-Fiction; History/My Choice

Grades: 3-5

ISBN: 978-0-8234-1831-6

The story of a girl who grew up in the Terezin concentration camp during WWII, and how art, opera, and friendship helped her survive.

My Thoughts:
I initially picked up this book because I had studied the art program at the Terezin concentration camp while taking a study abroad course in Prague as an undergraduate. The book far surpassed my expectations, and I feel that it is a great introduction for young readers to a very difficult topic. The subject matter is hard. People suffer, people die. The writers seem to take the view that children are resilient, and that while they need material at their level, they do not need to be sheltered from realities. Yet, even though the book is bleak, the messages of hope, perseverance, and the indomitability of the human spirit are inspiring. Readers will be able to identify with the main personages. By using children to put faces onto the events, modern children are provided with something familiar while trying to grasp events that will seem foreign.

One of the best things about this book is not the text though, its the artwork. There are TONS of photographs, both of the children and of the locations. Young readers need the visuals to be able to mentally visualize what is being described. Due to the time period almost all of the photographs are black and white, yet the book is full of color. Samples of the childen's artwork that was created in Terezin are interspersed throughout the text. It is awesome. I highly recommend this book, especially to people doing units on the holocaust or a unit on art.

The Thoughts of Others:
Booklist ran a review of the book by Hazel Rochman which appreciated above all how honest the book is. Rochman wrote that "there's a hopeful message about the power of music, art, friends, and teachers, but the account never denies the fact that transports were always leaving for the death camps and some of the prisoners did not survive."

Teri Markson's review for School Library Journal found the book "rich in detail, yet not overwhelmingly dire...a book about remembering, and the importance of sharing one's stories with the next generation, and the next." She truly liked the work, and was especially enamored with the amount of quotes and sources of information used.

Review: Golem

By: David Wisniewski

Clarion Books; 1996; 32 pages

Picture Book; Caldecott Winner

Grades: 1-4

ISBN: 978-0618894246

A re-telling of the story of Rabbi Loew and how the Golem he created saved the Jews of medieval Prague from persecution and annihilation.

My Thoughts:
My first impression of this book was one of awe. I have made snowflakes before, I know how difficult paper cutting is. The detail and impact of the illustrations is awe-inspiring. I kept looking at the pictures and thinking about how much Wisniewski had to plan out each page...and wondering how many mistakes he had to discard. On the merits of its illustrations, I agree wholeheartedly with this book receiving the Caldecott Medal. But, then I turned to the text.

The Golem legend is a difficult one for children. The reason for the Golem's creation is disturbing, how the Golem goes about protecting the Prague Jews is violent, and the destruction of the Golem at the end is unsettling. Joseph is shown to be very child-like in his wonder and view of the surrounding world. I would have a hard time explaining to kids why he is not rewarded for his help, but rather is destroyed. (His pleadings to live are heart-wrenching.) Because of this, I do not recommend this book for a younger audience. I can think of a few situations where it would work though: introducing older kids to the topics of persecution (before discussing the Inquisition or even the Holocaust...especially with the historical note at the end, it is a good way to discuss the historical oppression of Jews.), or in an older student unit on legend, or religion, or Prague.

The Thoughts of Others:

Publisher's Weekly emphasized the beauty and the intricacy of the illustrations, justifying its Caldecott. However, they also point out, albeit positively that Wisniewski "emphasizes the Golem's humanity and the problems with his existence [and] allows for its historical and emotional complexity." They also appreciated the historical endnote.

Common Sense Media, a group who reviews books for families, was impressed by the illustrations, but felt that Wisniewski's book might be frightening or distressing to younger readers. In the end, they pointed out that readers who could handle the story matter would actually be better served byBashevis Singer's version of the tale, also entitled The Golem.