Review: Runny Babbit

A Billy Sook By Shel Silverstein

HarperCollins; 2005; 89 Pages

Juvenile Non-Fiction; Poetry

Ages: 4(read aloud to) -10 (independent reading)

ISBN: 0-06-025653-2

A posthumous book of poetry centering on a single character, Runny Babbit, and his world of mixed up phonemes!

My Thoughts:
Of course I loved this book. Not only does this book center around a rabbit main character, it also derives most of its humor from wordplay. In fact, to be honest, many of the poems, if read straight, are really not all that amusing. However, with the first sound of many of the words swapped, hilarity ensues. Some of the themes, such as knitting and reading, were personally intriguing as well. The book is not as diverse in meter, theme, and length as other Silverstein books. In fact, to some extent, I would not recommend sitting down and reading it straight through in one go. It's humor holds up better in smaller chunks.

This is a good book to introduce children to poetry. The poems are short, cleverly illustrated, and entertaining. This would also be a good book to use as a public speaking or recitation exercise. The poems beg to be read aloud...I would venture that they HAVE to be read aloud in order to be properly enjoyed. The intricate phoneme swaps would encourage children to enunciate and pay close attention to their words, while the poems are brief enough to keep recitation from being an ordeal.

The Thoughts of Others:
Lee Bock of School Library Journal in 2005 wrote that "children will love these clever poems and without prompting will probably create their own, unaware that they are focusing on a key reading skill: phonemic awareness."

Kirkus Reviews published a review of Runny Babbit in March of 2005. They enjoyed it overall, but felt it "plays too long on a single trope."

Review: Mother Goose's Little Treasures

By Iona Opie; Illustrated by Rosemary Wells

Candlewick Press; 2007; 56 pages

Picture Book; Mother Goose

Ages: 2-6

ISBN: 978-0-7636-3655-5

A collection of lesser known Mother Goose nursery rhymes paired with Rosemary Wells' signature illustrations.

My Thoughts:

Nursery Rhyme books, specifically Mother Goose, tend to all be the same. Shorter collections always default to the same handful of rhymes. In this book, however, Opie has chosen several rhymes that I had never seen before, and several that are lesser known. (Although, it should be pointed out, that for at least a few of them there might be good reasons for them being lesser known!) It was exciting to read this book, because you couldn't predict what the next page would bring. For parents, more interested in the history of nursery rhymes, there is an introductory letter from the author.

This is also a great read aloud book for younger audiences. The ratio of illustration to text is perfect. There are full page color illustrations that are usually paired with only a few lines of text. Some rhymes take 4 to 5 pages to play out. This makes it suitable for much shorter attention spans. Also, the illustrations themselves are charming. Children who are already familiar with Wells' bunnies will love to see them dancing along with children, cats, dogs, and poultry.

The Thoughts of Others:

School Library Journal's 2007 review did praise the work, but pointed out that since the rhymes are lesser known, the book is a non-essential addition to library and personal collections. They suggested only acquiring it after the previous two in Opie and Wells' series.

Lauralynn Persson also reviewed the book for Publisher's Weekly. She felt that the book was better suited to those who love nursery rhymes, rather than introducing new children to the genre. Also, while she appreciated the illustrations, she felt that they ended up being washed out in production.